The Advantages of Narrow Reading

The Lexical Advantages of Narrow Reading for Second Language Learners
By Norbert Schmitt & Ronald Carter

According to the authors, integrating narrow reading in the early developmental stages of childhood is a crucial factor in language learning. Schmitt and Carter specify that reading should be a key component in most language learning programs. They explain how incorporating Narrow Reading into the syllabus can have a dramatically positive impact on the learner’s reading ability by encouraging the student to move onto more challenging readings. However, the authors do mention that maintaining the students’ interest is a key factor in determining ones motivation with regards to the readings, which is why it is important for teachers to allot a certain amount of choice to the students.
Moreover, the authors found that simplified readers are great tools for beginner students, but the students will gradually move onto rather authentic texts. In other words, Narrow Reading can be used as a stepping stone for students as they transition to these literary pieces. All in all, Schmitt and Carter found the results to be positive and recommend teachers to incorporate Narrow Reading into their course plans in order to promote students’ autonomy and interest in reading.
Schmitt and Carter’s opinion with regards to Narrow Reading have an impact on their writing style. Their “pro” Narrow Reading opinion translates itself into the text through their arguments as well as their text construction. For instance, the text is practically solely based on the benefits of incorporating this learning strategy into the classroom. However the authors do provide statistical elements in order to prove their case. In addition, the title of the article also conveys the essence of the text.

Strategy Used:
Describe the author’s point of view. How does the author’s attitude shape the way the writer presents the material?